What Is a Positive Butterfly?
A positive butterfly is a non-parallel yield curve shift that occurs when short- and long-term interest rates shift upward by a greater magnitude than medium-term rates. This shift effectively decreases the overall curvature of the yield curve.
- A positive butterfly occurs when there is a non-equal shift in a yield curve caused by long- and short-term yields rising by a higher degree than medium-term yields.
- A butterfly suggests a "twisting" of the yield curve, creating less curvature.
- A common bond trading strategy when the yield curve presents a positive butterfly is to buy the "belly" and sell the "wings".
Understanding Positive Butterflies
The yield curve is a visual representation that plots the yields of similar-quality bonds against their maturities, ranging from shortest to longest. The yield curve shows the yields of bonds with maturities ranging from 3 months to 30 years and, thus, enables investors at a quick glance to compare the yields offered by short-term, medium-term, and long-term bonds.
The short end of the yield curve based on short-term interest rates is determined by expectations for the Federal Reserve (Fed) policy; it rises when the Fed is expected to raise rates and falls when interest rates are expected to be cut. The long end of the yield curve, on the other hand, is influenced by factors such as the outlook on inflation, investor demand and supply, economic growth, institutional investors trading large blocks of fixed-income securities, etc.
In a normal interest rate environment, the curve slopes upward from left to right, indicating a normal yield curve. However, the yield curve changes when prevailing interest rates in the markets change. When the yields on bonds change by the same magnitude across maturities, we call the change a parallel shift. Alternatively, when the yields change in different magnitudes across maturities, the resulting change in the curve is a non-parallel shift.
A non-parallel change in interest rates may lead to a negative or positive butterfly, which are terms used to describe the shape of the curve after it shifts. The connotation of a butterfly is given because the intermediate maturity sector is likened to the body of the butterfly and the short maturity and long maturity sectors are viewed as the wings of the butterfly.
Positive vs. Negative Butterflies
The negative butterfly occurs when short-term and long-term interest rates decrease by a greater degree than intermediate-term rates, accentuating the hump in the curve. Conversely, a positive butterfly occurs when short-term and long-term interest rates increase at a higher rate than intermediate-term rates.
Put another way, medium-term rates increase at a lesser rate than short- and long-term rates, causing a non-parallel shift in the curve that makes the curve less humped—that is, less curved. For example, assume the yields on one-year Treasury bills (T-bills) and 30-year Treasury bonds (T-bonds) move upward by 100 basis points (1%). If during the same period, the rate of 10-year Treasury notes (T-notes) remains the same, the convexity of the yield curve will increase.
Buying the Belly of the Butterfly
A common bond trading strategy when the yield curve undergoes a positive butterfly is to buy the "belly" and sell the "wings". This simply means that bond traders will sell the relatively lower-yielding short- and long-term bonds (the wings) of the yield curve, and at the same time buy the relatively higher-yielding intermediate bonds (the belly). In this way, traders will attempt to even out their exposure to bond maturities that are shifting out of parallel and hope to profit from a return to the normal yield curve shape.
In reality, bond traders will factor in many variables when strategizing buy and sell orders, including the average maturity date of bonds in their portfolio. But, the shape of the yield curve is nonetheless an important indicator.