DEFINITION of 'Pushing On A String'

Pushing on a string is a metaphor for the limits of monetary policy and the impotence of central banks. Monetary policy sometimes only works in one direction because businesses and households cannot be forced to spend if they do not want to. Increasing the monetary base and banks’ reserves will not stimulate an economy if banks think it is too risky to lend and the private sector wants to save more because of economic uncertainty.

BREAKING DOWN 'Pushing On A String'

While the phrase pushing on a string has been attributed to British economist John Maynard Keynes, there is no evidence he used it. However, this exact metaphor was used in a House Committee on Banking and Currency in 1935, when Federal Reserve Governor Marriner Eccles told Congress that there was very little, if anything, that the Fed might do to stimulate the economy and end the Great Depression:

Governor Eccles: Under present circumstances there is very little, if anything, that can be done.
Congressman T. Alan Goldsborough: You mean you cannot push a string.
Governor Eccles: That is a good way to put it, one cannot push a string. We are in the depths of a depression and…, beyond creating an easy money situation through reduction of discount rates and through the creation of excess reserves, there is very little, if anything that the reserve organization can do toward bringing about recovery.

Given that trillions of dollars of quantitative easing (QE) failed to stimulate the U.S. economy as much as expected — even with the federal funds rate at near zero percent for seven years — the pushing on a string metaphor is relevant.

Saving the global economy was left almost entirely to central bankers, but they were unable to magic demand out of thin air because households, burdened with debt, increased their savings rate. Monetary policy has appeared desperate and futile, with the increase in money supply in the U.S. offset by declining money velocity.

When the Fed began its purchases, the U.S. appeared to be in a Keynesian liquidity trap, in which everyone hoards cash rather than spend it or lend it. Household debt fell until 2013, before rebounding to a record $13 trillion at the end of 2017. However, real wages remained flat in the gig economy because asset-price inflation hiked rents.

QE may have staved off disaster — though we will never know how much worse the crisis would have been without it. The multi-trillion dollar question is what happens to consumer spending and business investment as the Fed reduces the money supply and the cost of borrowing rises.

RELATED TERMS
  1. Accommodative Monetary Policy

    Accommodative monetary policy occurs when a central bank attempts ...
  2. Keynesian Economics

    Keynesian Economics is an economic theory of total spending in ...
  3. Quantitative Easing

    Quantitative easing is a monetary policy in which a central bank ...
  4. Monetary Base

    A monetary base is the total amount of a currency in general ...
  5. Federal Reserve System - FRS

    The Federal Reserve System, commonly known as the Fed, is the ...
  6. Zero-Bound Interest Rate

    A zero-bound interest rate is the lower limit of zero on short-term ...
Related Articles
  1. Insights

    Quantitative Easing is Now a Fixture, Not a Temporary Patch

    Rather than being a temporary patch, QE (quantitative easing) is now a fixture in global economic policy, for good or for bad.
  2. Investing

    Does Quantitative Easing Work?

    The US, Japan, and now the EU have embraced quantitative easing. But what works for the economy of one country doesn't necessarily work for another's.
  3. Investing

    Quantitative Easing: Does It Work?

    This controversial monetary policy has been used by some of the world's most powerful economies. But does it work?
  4. Insights

    The Top 6 Ways Governments Fight Deflation

    Here are six monetary and fiscal policy tools that governments use to fight deflation.
  5. Insights

    Why Deflation Is The Fed's Worst Nightmare

    The measures taken by central banks seem to be winning the battle against deflation, but it is too early to tell if they have won the war.
  6. Insights

    Can Keynesian Economics Reduce Boom-Bust Cycles?

    Learn about this famous British economist's proposed solution to a widespread economic problem.
  7. Investing

    How Negative Interest Rates Can Affect Currencies

    Analyze the relationship between interest rates and currency devaluation. Examine the impact of negative rates and how further declines could affect currencies.
RELATED FAQS
  1. What are some examples of expansionary monetary policy?

    Learn about expansionary monetary policy and how central banks use discount rates, reserve ratios and purchases of securities ... Read Answer >>
  2. How does monetary policy influence inflation?

    Take a deeper look at how contemporary central banks attempt to target and control the level of inflation through monetary ... Read Answer >>
  3. How Central Banks Influence Money Supply

    Central banks use several different methods to increase (or decrease) the amount of money in the banking system. Learn more ... Read Answer >>
  4. Did the Federal Reserve's quantitative easing add to M1?

    The Fed printed trillions of dollars to fund quantitative easing, right? So what happened to M1? Read Answer >>
  5. How do central banks acquire currency reserves and how much are they required to ...

    A currency reserve is a currency that is held in large amounts by governments and other institutions as part of their foreign ... Read Answer >>
Trading Center