What is the 'Ricardo-Barro Effect'

The Ricardo-Barro effect, also known as Ricardian equivalence, is an economic theory that suggests that when a government tries to stimulate an economy by increasing debt-financed government spending, demand remains unchanged, because the public increases their saving to pay for expected future tax increases that will be used to pay off the debt.

BREAKING DOWN 'Ricardo-Barro Effect'

While the Ricardo-Barro effect was developed by David Ricardo in the 19th century, it was revised by Harvard professor Robert Barro into a more elaborate version of the same concept. His theory stipulates that a person's consumption is determined by the lifetime present value of his after-tax income — their intertemporal budget constraint. So, government cannot stimulate consumer spending since people assume that whatever is gained now will be offset by higher taxes due in the future. It also implies that no matter how a government chooses to increase spending by borrowing or raising taxes, demand will remain unchanged, because debt-financed public spending will "crowd out" private spending.

Arguments Against the Ricardo-Barro Effect

The major arguments against the Ricardo-Barro effect are due to what are perceived as the unrealistic assumptions on which the theory is based. These assumptions include the existence of perfect capital markets and the ability for individuals to borrow and save whenever they want. Additionally, there is the assumption that individuals are willing to save for a future tax increase, which they may not see it in their lifetime. This does not ring true today, when U.S. personal saving rate has fallen to multi-decade lows, even as U.S. government borrowing soars. People just don’t seem to behave in a way that is consistent with Ricardian equivalence.

The Eurozone Provides Some Evidence of Ricardian Equivalence

There is no evidence that the Ricardo-Barro effect changed saving when the Reagan administration cut taxes and hiked military spending between 1981-85. In fact, net private saving as a percentage of GNP fell to 7.47% during the 1981-86 period, from 8.5% in 1976-80. The eurozone financial crisis has provided some evidence to support Ricardian equivalence. Based on data from 2007, there is a strong correlation between government debt burdens and changes in households’ financial assets for 12 of the 15 countries within the union.

  1. Savings Rate

    Savings rate is the percentage of money take from personal income ...
  2. The Wealth Effect

    The wealth effect in behavioral finance suggests that investors ...
  3. Personal Spending Plan

    A personal spending plan, similar to a budget, helps outline ...
  4. National Savings Rate

    An estimate known as the national savings rate gauges the amount ...
  5. Deficit Spending

    Deficit spending occurs whenever a government's expenditures ...
  6. Consumer Spending

    Consumer spending is the amount of money spent by households ...
Related Articles
  1. Taxes

    How Tax Cuts Stimulate the Economy

    Learn the logic behind the belief that reducing government income benefits everyone.
  2. Insights

    The U.S. National Spending And Debt

    Just like any average American household, government overspending can carry on for extended periods by rolling over debt and borrowing more and more money in what seems like a never-ending game ...
  3. Taxes

    Why America's Taxes Are Too Low

    The solution to America's economic woes may not be in lowering taxes further, but may, in fact, lie in increasing them.
  4. Financial Advisor

    10 Ways to Effectively Save for the Future

    Savings is as crucial as ever, as we deal with life changes and our needs for the future. Here are some essential steps to get started, now.
  5. Personal Finance

    How Savings Are Saving The Economy

    Even with inflation fears, saving money is still sage advice in a recovering economy.
  6. Insights

    Can Keynesian Economics Reduce Boom-Bust Cycles?

    Learn about this famous British economist's proposed solution to a widespread economic problem.
  7. Retirement

    Are You Saving Too Much?

    Can experts who advise 'Spend now!' possibly be right about saving too much?
  8. Taxes

    How Taxes Affect The Economy

    Learn how tax changes have historically affected the economy over the past three decades.
  9. Personal Finance

    The Key to Financial Independence? Saving Money

    If you struggle to save money consider these steps to get started.
  1. How can a change in fiscal policy have a multiplier effect on the economy?

    Learn about how changes in fiscal policy have a multiplier effect on the economy. The goal of expansionary fiscal policy ... Read Answer >>
  2. What effect does the income effect have on my business?

    Learn if you should open or modify your existing small business based on the income effect. Learn if it would positively ... Read Answer >>
Trading Center