What is 'Risk Shifting'

Risk shifting is the transfer of risk to another party. Risk shifting has many connotations, the most common being the tendency of a company or financial institution facing financial distress to take on excessive risk. This high-risk behavior is typically undertaken with the objective of generating high rewards for equity owners — who face little additional downside risk, but may garner significant extra return — and has the effect of shifting risk from shareholders to debt holders.

Risk shifting also occurs when a company changes from offering employees a defined benefit plan to offering a defined contribution plan. In this case, the risk associated with pensions has shifted from the company to its employees.

BREAKING DOWN 'Risk Shifting'

Risk shifting for a troubled company with significant debt occurs because, as its shareholders’ equity decreases, the stake of debt holders in the enterprise increases. Thus, if the company takes on more risk, the potential extra profits accrue to the shareholders, while the downside risk falls to the debt holders, which means that risk has shifted from the former to the latter.

Since management is not liable for losses incurred, financial institutions in potential or actual distress often engage in risky lending, which can negatively impact an economy by fueling asset bubbles and banking crises. (For more, see: How Do Asset Bubbles Cause Recessions?)

Risk Shifting Example

In a research paper from October 2011, the International Monetary Fund cites New Century Financial — a large subprime originator — as a classic example of risk shifting. The IMF paper notes the Federal Reserve’s tightening of monetary policy in 2004 resulted in an “adverse shock” to New Century’s large portfolio of loans it was holding for investment. New Century responded to this shock by resorting to the large-scale peddling of "interest-only" loans, which were riskier and more sensitive to real estate prices than standard loans.

This risk shifting behavior was also apparent in the business practices of other subprime mortgage loan originators, which fueled the U.S. housing bubble in the first decade of the 2000s, the subsequent collapse of which caused the most significant global banking crisis and recession since the 1930s.

Risk Shifting Alternatives

Risk management may be preferable to risk shifting by distressed companies and institutions. The risk management strategy focuses on balancing risk and returns to generate cash flow that is sufficient to meet financial obligations, rather than taking the “shoot the lights out” approach of risk shifting. Companies have faced stricter regulation since the Great Recession to encourage a more prudent approach to managing risk.

RELATED TERMS
  1. Accepting Risk

    Accepting risk occurs when a business acknowledges that the potential ...
  2. Business Risk

    Business risk is the possibility a company will have lower than ...
  3. Operational Risk

    Operational risk summarizes the risks a company undertakes when ...
  4. Risk Discount

    A risk discount refers to a situation where an investor is willing ...
  5. Price Risk

    Price risk is the risk of a decline in the value of a security ...
  6. Risk Management

    Risk management occurs anytime an investor or fund manager analyzes ...
Related Articles
  1. Personal Finance

    Risk Management Framework (RMF): An Overview

    A company must identify the type of risks it is taking, as well as measure, report on, and set systems in place to manage and limit, those risks.
  2. Investing

    The Risks Associated with Common Investments

    Investing inherently involves some risk. Here are some of the different types of investment risks.
  3. Insights

    How to Invest In Developing Markets

    Developing markets can be attractive additions to many investor's portfolios, but carry additional risks that must be considered.
  4. Small Business

    Identifying and managing business risks

    Running a business comes with a lot of associated risks, but there are an equal number of ways to prepare for and manage them to lessen their impact.
  5. Investing

    Understanding Risk is Key to Your Investing Strategy

    Here's why considering all types of risk is crucial for a successful investment plan.
  6. Personal Finance

    What Does It Really Mean to Be Risk Averse?

    We can’t really get away from risk and there are many meanings for this thing we call risk.
  7. Financial Advisor

    The Importance of a Client's Risk Assessment

    Financial advisors and money managers must do a detailed risk assessment regarding each client before they can recommend a course of action.
  8. Investing

    Financial Institutions: Stretched Too Thin?

    Find out how to evaluate a firm's loan portfolio to determine its financial health.
  9. Trading

    What Is Your Risk Tolerance?

    Forget the cliches and uncover how much volatility you can really stand.
  10. Investing

    The Pros and Cons of Distressed Debt Investing

    Distressed debt investing is suitable for professional investors. Besides heavy risk factors to consider, this investment type can provide a large ROI.
RELATED FAQS
  1. What are the major categories of financial risk for a company?

    Examine four major categories of financial risk for a business that represent potential problems that a company may have ... Read Answer >>
  2. Why are mutual funds subject to market risk?

    Find out why mutual funds, like all investments, are subject to market risk, including how the different types of market ... Read Answer >>
  3. What's the difference between EaR, Value at Risk (VaR), and EVE?

    Learn about earnings at risk, value at risk and economic value added, how these risk measures are used, and the difference ... Read Answer >>
  4. How do modern companies assess business risk?

    Find out how modern companies assess and mitigate business risks, how those risks can be identified and categorized, and ... Read Answer >>
  5. What is happening during a risk repricing?

    During a strong bull market, the market's overall sense of optimism can often lead to poor estimates about the level of risk ... Read Answer >>
  6. What is backtesting in Value at Risk (VaR)?

    The value at risk is a statistical risk management technique that monitors and quantifies the risk level associated with ... Read Answer >>
Trading Center