What are 'Robber Barons'

A robber baron is one of America’s successful industrialists during the 19th century, which was also known as the Gilded Age. A robber baron is a term that is also sometimes attributed to any successful businessman or woman whose practices are considered unethical or unscrupulous. This can include employee or environmental abuse, stock market manipulation or restricting output to charge higher prices.

BREAKING DOWN 'Robber Barons'

Robber barons were widely despised and considered rapacious monopolists during their lifetimes. However, later biographies and historical reviews about the Gilded Age’s American robber barons cast a more complicated and favorable light.

Use and Origin of the Term

The first known uses of the phrase “robber baron” described feudal lords in medieval Europe who literally robbed travelers, often merchant ships along the Rhine River, as they passed nearby. The term appeared in American newspapers in 1859. Its modern use stems from Matthew Josephson’s “The Robber Barons” (1934).

Robber Barons and Anti-Trust

A chief complaint against the 19th century capitalists was that they were monopolists. Fear over the robber barons and their monopoly practices increased public support for the Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890.

Economic theory says a monopolist earns premium profits by restricting output and raising prices. This only occurs after the monopolist prices out or legally restricts any competitor firms in the industry. However, there is no historical evidence that natural monopolies formed before the Sherman Antitrust Act.

Many so-called robber barons — James J. Hill, Henry Ford, Andrew Carnegie, Cornelius Vanderbilt and John D. Rockefeller — became wealthy entrepreneurs through product innovation and business efficiency. Of the goods and services they provided, supply grew and prices fell rapidly, greatly boosting Americans’ standards of living. This is the opposite of monopolistic behavior.

Others — including Robert Fulton, Edward K. Collins and Leland Stanford — earned their wealth through political entrepreneurship. Many wealthy railroad tycoons during the 1800s received privileged access and financing from the government via extensive use of lobbyists. They received monopolistic special licenses, per-mile subsidies, huge land grants and low-interest loans.

American Robber Barons: A Complicated History

Other common criticisms of the early robber barons included poor working conditions for employees, selfishness and greed. A deeper historical review reveals a complicated history.

Working conditions in 19th century America were often challenging, but workers may have been better off working for a robber baron. Rockefeller and Ford, for example, paid higher-than-average wages, including bonuses for innovation or exceptional production. Managers often received long vacations at full pay.

Some tycoons rank among the most noted philanthropist of all time. Rockefeller donated at least 6 to 10% of every paycheck he ever earned; this later increased to 50%. He gave over $550 million to charity and championed biomedical research, public sanitation, medical training and educational opportunities for disadvantaged minorities.

Carnegie gave over $350 million. James J. Hill publicized and provided free education about crop diversification, along with free seed grain, cattle and wood to local communities. He would even transport immigrants at reduced rates if they promised to farm near his railroads.

  1. Monopolistic Market

    A monopolistic market is typically dominated by one supplier ...
  2. Monopolistic State Fund

    A monopolistic state fund is a government owned and operated ...
  3. Tycoon

    A tycoon is a prominent figure in a particular industry who has ...
  4. Price Maker

    A price maker is an entity with a monopoly that has the power ...
  5. Rate Of Return Regulation

    Rate of return regulation is a form of price setting regulation ...
  6. Mogul

    A mogul is an individual who has been very successful in business ...
Related Articles
  1. Financial Advisor

    Top Baron Capital Funds for Retirement

    Discover seven mutual funds from Baron Capital that provide excellent diversification to the growth-oriented portion of a retirement savings portfolio.
  2. Insights

    Cornelius Vanderbilt Biography

    “Commodore” Cornelius Vanderbilt (1794-1877) was born into a poor family and quit school at age 11, but his shrewd – some would say ruthless – approach to business allowed him to consolidate ...
  3. Investing

    Wall Street History: A Robber Baron And A Beer Baron

    This week in financial history sees the birth of Bud and the richest man in history.
  4. Personal Finance

    The Evolution of Banking Over Time

    Discover how the evolution of banking has changed the business model. Find out how this system of money management developed into what we know today.
  5. Investing

    Tesla Sheds More Executives, Holds Hackathon to Fix Bottlenecks

    As electric-car maker Tesla suffers production woes, it's also losing top talent.
  6. Investing

    Understanding the Probabilities of Investing

    Safe but underperforming investments will lose you money in the long-run.
  1. What is the difference between a monopolistic market and perfect competition?

    Learn about monopolistic and perfectly competitive markets, what they are, and the main differences between perfect competition ... Read Answer >>
  2. What is the history of corporations in America?

    Read a short history of the American corporation, from the first industrial producers to the period of American business ... Read Answer >>
  3. Why Did Microsoft Face Antitrust Charges in 1998?

    Discover why the Department of Justice filed antitrust charges against Microsoft in 1998 over alleged monopolistic actions ... Read Answer >>
  4. Why do utility stocks pay high dividends?

    Learn why utility stocks pay high dividends, and how government-produced monopoly authority protects privileged utility companies ... Read Answer >>
  5. What is the difference between perfect and imperfect competition?

    Learn the differences between perfect competition and imperfect competition and what types of markets are considered imperfectly ... Read Answer >>
  6. How does a monopoly contribute to market failure?

    Read a simple overview of the theory of market monopoly, where it originated and some contemporary challenges to the classical ... Read Answer >>
Trading Center