What are 'Soft Dollars'

Soft dollars are a means of paying brokerage firms for their services through commission revenue, as opposed to through normal direct payments (hard-dollar fees). The investing public tends to have a negative perception of soft-dollar arrangements, because they believe that buy-side firms should pay expenses out of their profits, rather than from investors' pockets. As such, the use of hard-dollar compensation is becoming more common.

BREAKING DOWN 'Soft Dollars'

For example, a mutual fund may offer to pay for research from a brokerage firm by executing trades at the brokerage. Assume that a large-cap value fund wants to buy some research from XYZ Brokerage Firm. The fund may agree to spend at least $10,000 in commissions for brokerage services in return for the research; this would represent a soft-dollar payment. Alternatively, if the fund simply wanted to buy the research and not agree to any kind of soft-dollar fee, it might have to pay the brokerage firm $7,000 in hard dollars (cash) for the service.

How a Soft-Dollar Transaction Works

The commission for a trade that an institutional investor may have paid the brokerage firm is 6 cents per share, but it actually only cost 3 cents per share. The other 3 cents are used for soft-dollar rebates. Under this arrangement, the institutional investor is obligated to direct future trades to the brokerage firm. None of this presents a problem for the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) as long as the investor receives best execution and the commission is not unreasonably disparate from what is charged by other firms.

The Inherent Problems With Soft Dollars

The costs of research and other bundled services provided in the soft-dollar transaction are essentially borne by the mutual fund investor, yet they are not disclosed by the fund. They are simply built into the cost of trades, which impacts the long-term performance of the fund.

Technically, the mutual fund would disclose the hard cost of research in its management fee. However, when it is paid for with soft dollars, it is not paid from its management fee. The fund managers argue that the institutional investors ultimately bear all of the costs. However, using soft dollars to pay for research doesn't allow the mutual fund investor to conduct an accurate cost analysis when selecting the fund.

Soft dollar values are not determinable, nor are they equal. What one investment manager receives in the form of services may differ from what another manager receives. This opens the door for conflicts and abuses, and the mutual fund investors never know what portion of their transaction costs are applied to the soft services or their actual investment.

Although soft-dollar transactions are still widely used, there is a growing movement to eliminate them, especially as financial reform and issues of transparency dominate the industry.

Abuses of Soft Dollars

The haziness of soft dollars has made the practice subject to misuse by investment professionals and examination by the SEC. In one case in 2013, the SEC levied sanctions against New York brokerage firm Instinet LLC for not flagging payments of more than $400,000 in soft dollars to San Diego-based adviser J.S. Oliver Capital Management despite clear signs they were used for dubious purposes and not properly disclosed to clients. The SEC found that associates at J.S. Oliver Capital had used the soft dollars payments toward divorce expenses, rent payments and costs related to a personal timeshare. Ultimately, the SEC ruled that Instinet overlooked the misuse of the soft dollars and settled with the company for $800,000. 

  1. Soft Commissions

    A soft commission, or soft dollars, is a transaction-based payment ...
  2. Commission

    A commission is a service charge assessed by a broker or investment ...
  3. Soft Market

    A soft market is a phase in the economic cycle wherein there ...
  4. Soft Loan

    A soft loan is financing with no interest or a below-market rate ...
  5. Soft Sell

    Soft sell refers to an advertising and sales approach that features ...
  6. Soft Currency

    A soft currency is one that's value is inherently weak and not ...
Related Articles
  1. Trading

    Soft Commodities Could Bounce Higher This Week

    Despite major downtrends on the charts of soft commodities, active traders are taking a closer look because nearby support suggests prices could be readying for a bounce higher.
  2. Investing

    Mutual Fund Trading Rules

    Make sure to review this guide on the dos and don'ts of mutual fund trading before you invest, including how trades are executed and which fees to look out for.
  3. Investing

    Why Discount Brokerages Aren't Always a Bargain

    Discount brokerage firms and robo-advisors claim to be cheaper, but that isn't always the case.
  4. Investing

    Consider These Fees When Evaluating Mutual Funds

    The best way to evaluate a mutual fund is by digging a bit deeper into the fees charged.
  5. Investing

    Analyst Recommendations: Do Sell Ratings Exist?

    Analyst reports can be an investor's best friend - but without knowing how to read them, you won't be able to fully utilize them.
  6. Investing

    Full-Service Brokerage or DIY?

    Determine what you are getting for your fees and commissions and whether to use a broker or do it yourself.
  7. Investing

    When to buy a mutual fund

    Doing a little research can help you find out if mutual funds are a good fit for your portfolio.
  8. Investing

    Active Traders Are Turning to Soft Commodities for Answers

    Based on the charts of these exchange traded notes now is the time to buy soft commodities such as coffee and sugar.
  1. What are soft dollars?

    The term 'soft dollars' refers to mutual funds making in-kind payments to their service providers; for instance, by passing ... Read Answer >>
Trading Center