Loading the player...

WHAT IS 'Tax Differential View Of Dividend Policy'

The tax differential view of dividend policy is the belief that shareholders prefer equity appreciation to dividends because capital gains are effectively taxed at lower rates than dividends when the investment time horizon and other factors are considered. Corporations that adopt this viewpoint generally have lower targeted payout ratios, or a long-term dividend-to-earnings ratio, as dividend payments are set rather than variable.

BREAKING DOWN 'Tax Differential View Of Dividend Policy'

The tax differential view is part of a debate over dividends vs. equity growth that is old but still vigorous. The payment of dividends to shareholders can be traced back to the origins of modern corporations. In the 16th century, sailing captains in England and Holland sold shares of their upcoming voyage to investors; at the end of the voyage whatever capital was earned from trading or, as the case may be, plunder would be divided among the investors and the venture shut down. Eventually it became more efficient to create an ongoing joint stock company, with shares sold on exchanges and dividends allotted per share. Before the advent of rigorous corporate earnings reports, dividends were the most reliable way to capitalize on investments.

However, with growing corporations and stock exchanges came an increase in corporate reporting, making it more feasible to track long-term investments based on rising share value. Moreover, for much of modern financial history dividends have been taxed at a higher rate than capital gains from stock sales. In the United States however, both forms of income are now taxed at the same rate, up to 20 percent depending on total income.

Tax Differential Is a Long-Term Difference

Despite the equitable tax rate, dividends are taxed every year while capital gains are not taxed until the stock is sold; that time factor means the equity investment increases tax-free and thus grows exponentially faster. Thus proponents of equity over dividends say the tax preference still holds. Moreover, they argue that companies assuming a tax differential viewpoint are focused on share appreciation and thus often have more funds available for growth and expansion than companies focused merely on increasing their dividends. That growth in turn, they argue, increases share value.

A counter argument is that dividend payouts are a sure thing while company growth is unpredictable. This is the so-called “bird in the hand” argument. Proponents of this viewpoint also note that dividend payouts can actually increase a company’s share value, since the dividends themselves are attractive to investors seeking regular income. Finally, a third argument is that dividends have no bearing on stock value. Despite decades of study, the question of dividends vs. equity remains unresolved.

  1. Stock Dividend

    A stock dividend, also known as a scrip dividend, is a dividend ...
  2. Gross Dividends

    Gross dividends are the sum total of all dividends received, ...
  3. Dividend Exclusion

    Dividend exclusion is a rule that allows corporations to subtract ...
  4. Cash Dividend

    Cash dividend is the money paid to stockholders normally as a ...
  5. Dividend Aristocrat

    A dividend aristocrat is a company that has continuously increased ...
  6. Preferred Dividend Coverage Ratio

    The preferred dividend coverage ratio is the ratio that measures ...
Related Articles
  1. Investing

    Is Dividend Investing a Good Strategy?

    Understanding dividends and how they generate steady income for shareholders will help you become a more informed and successful investor.
  2. Investing

    Put Dividends to Work in Your Portfolio

    Find out how a company can put its profits directly into your hands.
  3. Investing

    WMT: Wal-Mart Dividend Analysis

    Wal-Mart raised its dividend for the 43rd consecutive year, despite losing over 25% of its market value in 2015, and its dividend remains healthy in 2016.
  4. Investing

    The Top 5 Dividend Paying Oil Stocks for 2016

    Discover the top five dividend-paying oil companies for 2016 and what factors contribute to their ability to continue dividend payments.
  5. Investing

    Dividend Growth Likely to Slow in 2017

    Investors who saw dividend increases in the past five years are likely to see them slow this year.
  6. Investing

    Dividend Yield For The Downturn

    High-dividend stocks make excellent bear market investments, but the payouts aren't a sure thing.
  7. Investing

    The Best 8 Funds For Regular Dividend Income

    Here's a list of the top mutual funds which pay regular dividends, for frequent income.
  8. Investing

    Dividend ETFs Sought for Solid Revenue Streams

    Dividends can be found with plenty of ETFs, but investors should study up before committing capital.
  1. If I reinvest my dividends, are they still taxable?

    If you reinvest your dividends, you still pay taxes as though you received the cash. Stock dividends are generally not taxable ... Read Answer >>
Trading Center