What is a 'Trilemma'?

The impossible trinity, also called the Mundell-Fleming trilemma or simply the trilemma, expresses the limited options available to countries in setting monetary policy. According to this theory, a country cannot achieve the free flow of capital, a fixed exchange rate and independent monetary policy simultaneously. By pursuing any two of these options, it necessarily closes off the third. 

BREAKING DOWN 'Trilemma'

The theory of the policy trilemma is frequently credited to the economists Robert Mundell and Marcus Fleming, who independently described the relationships among exchange rates, capital flows and monetary policy in the 1960s. Maurice Obstfeld, who became chief economist at the IMF in 2015, presented the model they developed as a "trilemma" in a 1997 paper. 

According to the trilemma model, a country has three options. It can

A - set a fixed exchange rate between its currency and another while allowing capital to flow freely across its borders,

B - allow capital to flow freely and set its own monetary policy, or

C - set its own monetary policy and maintain a fixed exchange rate.

A graphical representation of the trilemma theory.

The country cannot, however, fix exchange rates, allow capital to flow freely and maintain monetary policy sovereignty. For example, Country X links its currency, the X pound, to the Y franc at a one-to-one ratio. This is effective if both Country X and Country Y's central banks maintain a policy rate of 3%. But if Country Y raises interest rates to combat rising inflation, investors would spot an opportunity for arbitrage. X pounds would flood over the border to buy Y francs and earn the higher interest rate.

Y francs would in effect become worth more than X pounds. Thus, either Country X abandons the currency peg and allows the X pound to fall, raises its policy rate to match Country Y's policy rate abandoning monetary policy independence or it sets up capital controls to keep X pounds in the country.

Real-world examples of these trade-offs include the eurozone where countries have opted for side A of the triangle: they forfeit monetary policy control to the European Central Bank but maintain a single currency (in effect a one-to-one peg coupled with free capital flow). The difficulties of maintaining a monetary union across economies as different as Germany and Greece have become clear as the latter has repeatedly appeared poised to drop out of the currency bloc

Following World War II, the wealthy opted for side C under the Bretton Woods system, which pegged currencies to the dollar but allowed them to set their own interest rates. Cross-border capital flows were so small that the system held for a couple of decades – the exception being Mundell's native Canada, a situation that gave him special insight into the tensions inherent in the system. Today, most countries allow their currencies to float, meaning they opt for side B.

The French economist Hélène Rey has argued that the trilemma is not as simple as it appears since most countries lack monetary policy independence whether or not they have free exchange rates and capital flows. The reason is the overwhelming influence of the Federal Reserve

RELATED TERMS
  1. Joint Float

    A joint float is when two or more countries keep their currencies ...
  2. Fixed Exchange Rate

    A fixed exchange rate is a regime where the official exchange ...
  3. Floating Exchange Rate

    A floating exchange rate is a regime where a nation's currency ...
  4. Monetary Policy

    Monetary policy is the actions of a central bank, currency board ...
  5. Currency Union

    A currency union is where more than one country or area shares ...
  6. Key Currency

    A key currency used is money issued by stable, developed country ...
Related Articles
  1. Insights

    How Monetary Policy Affects Your Investments

    Monetary policy changes can have a significant impact on every asset class. investors can position their portfolios to benefit from policy changes and boost returns by being aware of the nuances ...
  2. Trading

    A Primer On Currency Regimes

    Currency regimes are dynamic and complex, reflecting the ever-changing landscape of their respective nations' monetary and fiscal policies.
  3. Insights

    How Much Influence Does The Fed Have?

    Find out how current financial policies may affect your portfolio's future returns.
  4. Insights

    A Look at Fiscal and Monetary Policy

    Learn more about which policy is better for the economy, monetary policy or fiscal policy. Find out which side of the fence you're on.
  5. Trading

    The British Pound: What Every Forex Trader Needs To Know

    As a strong alternative to the dollar it is likely that the pound will remain a preeminent global currency for some time to come.
  6. Trading

    Top Exchange Rates Pegged to the U.S. Dollar

    From the end of World War II until around 1971, all countries in the IMF pegged their currencies to the U.S. dollar. Today, many still do.
  7. Trading

    Interest Rate and Currency Value And Exchange Rate

    In general, higher interest rates in one country tend to increase the value of its currency.
  8. Insights

    Understanding The Currency Board vs Central Bank

    Each is different in their own way, but which system is better: the currency board or the central bank? Find out more about these systems in this article.
RELATED FAQS
  1. What indicators are used in exchange rate forecasting?

    Learn what economic indicators are most widely used to forecast a country’s exchange rate and how various foreign exchange ... Read Answer >>
  2. What is foreign exchange?

    Foreign exchange is the conversion of a country's currency into another. In a free economy, a country's currency is valued ... Read Answer >>
  3. What's the difference between monetary policy and fiscal policy?

    Discover the distinctions between these two tools designed to influence national economies. Read Answer >>
  4. How does the balance of payments impact currency exchange rates?

    Take a brief look at the relationship between a nation's balance of payments and the exchange rate value of its currency ... Read Answer >>
  5. What does a negative balance in the capital account mean?

    Understand what a country's capital account represents and the significance of a negative, or deficit, balance in the capital ... Read Answer >>
Trading Center