What is an 'Underinvestment Problem'

An underinvestment problem is an agency problem between shareholders and debt holders where a leveraged company foregoes valuable investment opportunities because debt holders would capture a portion of the benefits of the project, leaving insufficient returns to shareholders.

BREAKING DOWN 'Underinvestment Problem'

The underinvestment problem in corporate finance theory is credited to Stewart C. Myers of the Sloan School at MIT, who in his "Determinants of Corporate Borrowing" article (1977) in the Journal of Financial Economics hypothesized that "a firm with risky debt outstanding, and which acts in its stockholders' interest, will follow a different decision rule than one which can issue risk-free debt or which issues no debt at all.

The firm financed with risky debt will, in some states of nature, pass up valuable investment opportunities — opportunities which could make a positive net contribution to the market value of the firm." Also known as the "debt overhang problem," the underinvestment problem moves into focus when a firm frequently passes up net positive NPV projects because the managers, acting on behalf of shareholders, believe that creditors would benefit more than owners. If cash flows from a prospective investment go to creditors, then there would be no incentive to equity holders to proceed with the investment. Such an investment would increase the overall value of the firm, but it does not happen — hence, there is a "problem."

Contradicting Modigliani-Miller

The underinvestment problem theory conflicts with the assumption in the Modigliani-Miller theorem that investment decisions can be made independent of financing decisions. Managers of a leveraged company, Myers argues, do in fact take into consideration the amount of debt that needs to be serviced when evaluating a new investment project. According to Myers, the value of the firm can be influenced by financing decisions, in contradiction to Modigliani-Miller's central tenet.

RELATED TERMS
  1. Modigliani-Miller Theorem - M&M

    The Modigliani-Miller theorem states that a firm's value is based ...
  2. Agency Problem

    The agency problem is a conflict of interest where one party, ...
  3. Agency Cost of Debt

    Agency cost of debt is a problem arising from the conflict of ...
  4. Debt Overhang

    Debt overhang is a debt burden so large that an entity cannot ...
  5. Leverage

    Leverage results from using borrowed capital as a source of funding ...
  6. Funded Debt

    A funded debt is a company's debt that will mature in more than ...
Related Articles
  1. Investing

    Will Corporate Debt Drag Your Stock Down?

    Corporate debt can mean a leg up for firms, or the boot for investors. How to tell the difference.
  2. Insights

    How Debt Limits A Country's Options

    While debt is fundamentally necessary to the operation of a national government, it can also be limiting and dangerous.
  3. Insights

    How Countries Deal With Debt

    For many emerging economies, issuing sovereign debt is the only way to raise funds, but things can go sour quickly.
  4. Personal Finance

    Why Debt Isn’t Always a Bad Thing

    When managed properly, debt can be used to achieve a higher overall rate of return.
  5. Investing

    Sell UPS on Amazon Threat: Deutsche Bank

    Analysts highlight UPS' dismal capex guidance and underinvestment over the past decade.
  6. Investing

    4 Leverage Ratios Used In Evaluating Energy Firms

    These four leverage ratios can help investors evaluate how energy manage their debt.
  7. Insights

    What the National Debt Means to You

    The U.S. deficit seems to grow every year. But how does national debt actually affect you?
  8. Insights

    How High Levels of Debt Could Impact the Economy

    Here's how a large accumulation of private debt could impact the economy and investments.
  9. Financial Advisor

    The 4 Best Debt Reduction Services

    It can be tricky to find the best debt reduction services for your financial situation. These top 4 debt consolidation firms help make the process easier.
  10. Personal Finance

    What to know for an investment banking interview

    Find out what you need to know and how to prepare for an investment banking interview.
RELATED FAQS
  1. What are the benefits and shortfalls of the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index?

    Learn about the differences between equity and debt financing and how they impact financials. Find out how businesses determine ... Read Answer >>
  2. What does "agency cost of debt" mean?

    Agency cost of debt is an increase in debt costs as shareholder and management interests diverge. Find out why restrictions ... Read Answer >>
  3. Why would you look at a company's net debt rather than its gross debt?

    Learn the difference between net debt and gross debt, how to calculate debt using a company's financial statements and why ... Read Answer >>
  4. How is the principle agent problem manifested in the government?

    Learn more about the principal-agent problem and challenges this problem may create in the relationship between government ... Read Answer >>
Trading Center