What is 'Wisdom of Crowds'

Wisdom of crowds is the idea that large groups of people are collectively smarter than even individual experts when it comes to problem solving, decision making, innovating and predicting. The wisdom of crowds concept was popularized by James Surowiecki in his 2004 book, The Wisdom of Crowds, which shows how large groups have made superior decisions in pop culture, psychology, biology, behavioral economics and other fields.

BREAKING DOWN 'Wisdom of Crowds'

The idea of the wisdom of crowds can be traced back to Aristotle’s theory of collective judgment as presented in his work Politics. He used a potluck dinner as an example, explaining that a group of individuals may come together to create a more satisfying feast for a group as a whole than what one individual might provide.

Examples of Wisdom of Crowds

Here are two examples that show how the concept works.

1. By averaging together the individual guesses of a large group about the weight of an object, the answer may be more accurate than the guesses of experts most familiar with that object.

2. The collective judgment of a diverse group can compensate for the bias of a small group. In trying to guess the outcome of a World Series game, fans may be irrationally biased toward their preferred teams, but a large group that includes plenty of non-fans and individuals who dislike both World Series teams may be able to more accurately predict the winner.

What’s Needed to Form a Wise Crowd?

Crowds aren’t always wise. In fact, some can be the opposite. Take, for instance, frenzied investors who participate in a stock market bubble like the one that occurred in the 1990s with dotcom companies. The group, or crowd, involved in this bubble invested based on speculation that internet startups would become profitable at some point in the future. Many of these companies’ stock prices soared, despite the fact that they had yet to generate any revenue. Unfortunately, a good portion of the companies went under, as panic ensued in the markets following mass sell orders on the stocks of some of the major tech companies. 

But, according to Surowiecki, wise crowds have several key characteristics. First off, the crowd should be able to have a diversity of opinions. Secondly, one person’s opinion should remain independent of those around them (and should not be influenced by anyone else). Next, anyone taking part in the crowd should be able to make their own opinion based on their individual knowledge. Finally, the crowd should be able to aggregate the individual opinions into one collective decision. 

Wisdom of Crowds in Financial Markets

The wisdom of crowds can also help explain what makes markets, which are a type of crowd, efficient at times and inefficient at others. If market participants are not diverse and if they lack incentives, then markets will be inefficient and an item’s price will be out of step with its value.

In a 2015 Bloomberg View article, wealth manager and columnist Barry Ritholtz argued that prediction and futures markets, unlike markets for goods and services, lack the wisdom of crowds because they do not have a large or diverse pool of participants. He points out that prediction markets failed spectacularly in trying to guess the outcomes of events such as the Greek referendum, the Michael Jackson trial, and the 2004 Iowa primary. The individuals trying to predict the outcomes of these events were simply guessing based on public polling data and did not have any special individual or collective knowledge.

While there is merit to the idea that the many are smarter than the few, it is not always true, particularly when members of the crowd are aware of and are influenced by each other’s ideas. Consensus thinking among a group of people with poor judgment can, unsurprisingly, lead to poor group decision making; this factor may have been one of the causes of the 2008 financial crisis. It can also explain why democracies sometimes elect unqualified leaders. In other words, as explained by British science writer Philip Ball in a 2014 article for the BBC, it matters who is in the crowd.

  1. Bond Crowd

    The bond crowd describes bond traders on an exchange floor.
  2. Free-Crowd System

    A free-crowd system is a system of commodity trading in which ...
  3. Market Timing

    Market timing is the attempt to beat the market by predicting ...
  4. Outcome Bias

    Outcome bias is an error made in evaluating the quality of a ...
  5. Ponzi Mania

    Ponzi mania describes the mood of investors after Bernie Madoff's ...
  6. Rent-a-Crowd

    A rent-a-crowd is group of people rented to make a business, ...
Related Articles
  1. Trading

    How the Power of the Masses Drives the Market

    Market psychology is an undeniably powerful force. Find out what you can do about it.
  2. Trading

    An Introduction to Consensus Indicators

    Learn how the herd is almost always wrong, or at least late in jumping on the bandwagon.
  3. Trading

    Enter Trades Ahead Of The Emotional Crowd

    Traders profit in highly competitive markets by shifting their strategies backward or forward, entering positions ahead of or behind the emotional crowd.
  4. Trading

    Bucking The Trend With Pattern Failure Strategies

    The best trade could be in the opposite direction when a classic price pattern doesn't behave according to ideal rules.
  5. Investing

    Rules and Strategies For Profitable Short Selling

    Short sales work well in bull and bear markets but strict entry and risk management rules are required to overcome the threat of short squeezes.
  6. Investing

    Emerging Markets ETFs Could Keep Surging

    Investors are pouring into emerging markets ETFs, but the trade is not yet crowded.
  7. Tech

    Could the Recent Slump in Bitcoin Have Fostered Insider Trading?

    A recent tumble in the price of BTC has prompted speculation that insider trading has taken place.
  8. Investing

    Traps That Lead to Market Underperformance Part II

    There is a vicious investing cycle that impacts many young and first-time investors.
  9. Investing

    An Introduction to Behavioral Finance

    Curious about how emotions and biases affect the market? Find some useful insight here.
  10. Personal Finance

    Back to School: Not an Event But an Attitude

    It's back to school time, but when it comes to your finances, education and learning should be an ongoing process.
  1. Do budget deficits "crowd out" the market?

    Find out how governments can crowd out private investment and other borrowers in the market for loanable funds whenever they ... Read Answer >>
  2. Can the Efficient Market Hypothesis explain economic bubbles?

    Learn about the nuanced relationship between the efficient market hypothesis and economic bubbles and the requirements and ... Read Answer >>
Trading Center