1. Historical Performance Vs. Underlying Portfolio Characteristics
  2. Mutual Fund Performance Data
  3. Fund I-Q No.7: Comparative Total Returns
  4. Scoring Fund Performance Data

By Richard Loth (Contact | Biography)

This is the entry we need to complete in the Fund Investment-Quality Scorecard for an analysis of a mutual fund's performance data:



The Morningstar and Value Line reports provide comprehensive multi-year annualized total return data. The comparisons in the Morningstar and Value Line presentations express a fund's performance as above (+) or below (-) the peer, category, and/or index benchmark annualized total return figures.

For example, if the XYZ Fund has an annualized 10-year total return of 9.5%, and the S&P 500 Index had an equivalent total return of 8.2%, the comparison would be expressed as + 1.3% for the period. This figure indicates that XYZ's performance is above that of the S&P 500 Index by that percentage. Conversely, if the XYZ and S&P total returns were reversed, the comparison would be expressed as - 1.3%.

By looking at the fund's total return numbers in the performance overviews, particularly those in the five-year and 10-year periods, we can readily determine how a fund is performing compared to its relevant benchmarks. Look for managed funds to do better than their peers, category and index benchmarks; with index funds, try to match performance to a fund's tracking index. A positive performance differential between a fund and its benchmarks is a very favorable investment quality.

As was discussed previously in this chapter, it is prudent to cross-check the annualized total return figure against the fund's year-to-year figures. If XYZ Fund's 10-year annualized total return is 9.5%, the prudent fund investor will look at XYZ's past 10-year annual total returns to see if the annualized return is representative of its mean performance. Fairly steady, above-market tracking performance is indicative of fund investment quality.

Return to the Main Menu.
Proceed to the next chapter on Analytical Commentary on a Fund.


Related Articles
  1. Investing

    What Is Year Over Year?

    Year over year measures performance in one time period versus performance in a previous time period.
  2. Investing

    Calculating Annualized Total Return

    The annualized total return is the average return of an investment each year over a given time period.
  3. Investing

    Don’t Be Fooled Looking at Only Mutual Fund Rankings (MORN)

    Examine the pitfalls of investing in mutual funds based solely on each fund's ranking from major sources such as Morningstar or Lipper.
  4. Investing

    The Hidden Differences Between Index Funds

    These funds don't all match index returns. Find out how to avoid costly surprises.
  5. Investing

    Fund Management Issues

    The quality of management is a key component of a fund's success.
Frequently Asked Questions
  1. What is the difference between available credit and credit limit?

    Explore the difference between available credit and credit limit and the implications different account balances have on ...
  2. What are the differences between debit cards and credit cards?

    Learn how the major difference between a debit card and a credit card is where the money comes from when a customer makes ...
  3. Should I pay my mortgage with my credit card to earn credit card rewards?

    If you try, in order to earn cash back rewards, you'll discover that your options are extremely limited and are unlikely ...
  4. What's considered to be a good debt-to-income (DTI) ratio?

    Your debt-to-income ratio helps lenders determine your credit worthiness. Find out how to calculate your score and how to ...
Trading Center