1. Stock-Picking Strategies: Introduction
  2. Stock-Picking Strategies: Fundamental Analysis
  3. Fundamental Analysis: Figuring Discounted Cash Flow
  4. Stock-Picking Strategies: Qualitative Analysis
  5. Stock-Picking Strategies: Value Investing
  6. Stock-Picking Strategies: Growth Investing
  7. Stock-Picking Strategies: GARP Investing
  8. Stock-Picking Strategies: Income Investing
  9. Stock-Picking Strategies: CAN SLIM
  10. Stock-Picking Strategies: Dogs of the Dow
  11. Stock-Picking Strategies: Technical Analysis
  12. Stock-Picking Strategies: Conclusion

Now that we’ve looked at value and growth investing, we can explore a hybrid stock-picking system that combines theories from both schools: growth at a reasonable priceor GARP. GARP investors look for companies that are somewhat undervalued (a feature of value investing) with solid sustainable growth potential (a tenet of growth investing) – an approach that attempts to avoid the extremes of either value or growth investing.

The diagram below shows the preferred levels of price and growth for growth, GARP and value investors; note that GARP is nestled in between value and growth:

GARP Stocks – Not a “GARP-y” Portfolio

It’s worth noting that GARP investors do not simply hold portfolios with equal amounts of value and growth stocks that somehow average out be “GARP-y.” Instead, GARPers identify stocks on an individual basis and select those that have neither purely value nor purely growth characteristics, but a combination of the two. That’s not to say that GARP investors wouldn’t also have growth and value stocks in their portfolios as part of an overall investment strategy – it just wouldn’t be part of a GARP strategy.

What to Look For

Because GARP investors straddle the gap between value and growth investors, they use metrics from both schools to find appropriate investments. 

Value Metrics

GARP investors and value investors both pay close attention to a company’s present valuation, and both use the P/E ratio – the amount investors are willing to pay per dollar of earnings for a given company – to do so. In general, a low P/E can be a signal that a company is currently undervalued, or that it’s doing well compared to its past trends.

GARP investors generally aim for P/E ratios that are somewhat higher than what value investors look for, but well below the extremely high P/E ratios typically sought by growth investors. Keep in mind that – like many metrics – P/E should only be used to compare companies within the same sector. Comparing companies across different sectors can be misleading due to the various ways companies earn money – and the different timing for earning that money.

Another value metric used by both types of investors is the price-to-book (P/B) ratio, which compares a stock’s market value to its book value. It’s calculated by dividing the current closing price by the latest quarter’s book value per share. Value and GARP investors both look for a P/B that falls below the industry average.

Growth Metrics

Like growth investors, GARPers are interested in a company’s growth prospects: where the company will be in the next five to 10 years. Both types of investors look for positive earnings numbers over the past few years, plus positive earnings estimates for the next few years. Unlike growth investors, however, GARP investors steer clear of companies with extremely high growth estimates (e.g., those in the 25% to 50% range) because these investments are viewed as too risky. Instead, GARPers focus on more conservative earnings growth rates in the 10% to 20% range.

Like growth investors, GARPers are also interested in a company’s PEG ratio, a metric that gauges the balance between a stock’s growth potential and its value. Here's how it works.

The PEG Ratio
The PEG ratio may very well be the most important metric to any GARP investor, as it basically gauges the balance between a stock's growth potential and its value. (If you're unfamiliar with the PEG ratio, see: How the PEG Ratio Can Help Investors.)

GARP investors require a PEG no higher than 1 and, in most cases, closer to 0.5. A PEG of less than 1 implies that, at present, the stock's price is lower than it should be given its earnings growth. To the GARP investor, a PEG below 1 indicates that a stock is undervalued and warrants further analysis.

PEG at Work
Say the TSJ Sports Conglomerate, a fictional company, is trading at 19 times earnings (P/E = 19) and has earnings growing at 30%. From this you can calculate that the TSJ has a PEG of 0.63 (19/30=0.63), which is pretty good by GARP standards.

Now let's compare the TSJ to Cory's Tequila Co (CTC), which is trading at 11 times earnings (P/E = 11) and has earnings growth of 20%. Its PEG equals 0.55. The GARPer's interest would be aroused by the TSJ, but CTC would look even more attractive. Although it has slower growth compared to TSJ, CTC currently has a better price given its growth potential. In other words, CTC has slower growth, but TSJ's faster growth is more overpriced. As you can see, the GARP investor seeks solid growth, but also demands that this growth be valued at a reasonable price. Hey, the name does make sense!
 

 

When GARP Wins – and When It Doesn't

Because a GARP strategy employs principles from both value and growth investing, the returns that GARPers see during certain market phases are often different than the returns strictly value or growth investors would see at those times. For instance, in a raging bull market the returns from a growth strategy are often unbeatable: In the dotcom boom of the mid- to late-1990s, for example, neither the value investor nor the GARPer could compete. However, when the market does turn, a GARPer is less likely to suffer than the growth investor.

In short, the GARP strategy not only fuses growth and value stock-picking criteria, but also experiences a combination of their types of returns: A value investor will do better in bearish conditions; a growth investor will do exceptionally well in a raging bull market; and a GARPer will be rewarded with more consistent and predictable returns.

GARP might sound like the perfect strategy, but combining growth and value investing isn't as easy as it sounds. If you don't master both strategies, you could find yourself buying mediocre rather than good GARP stocks. But as many great investors such as Peter Lynch have proved, the returns are definitely worth the time it takes to learn the GARP techniques.


Stock-Picking Strategies: Income Investing
Related Articles
  1. Investing

    How to Analyze Mid-Cap Stocks

    Mid-cap stocks often outperform both large caps and small caps with very little added risk.
  2. Investing

    The 4 basic elements of stock value

    Investors use these four measures to determine a stock's worth. Find out how to use them.
  3. Investing

    5 must-have metrics for value investors

    In this article, we outline the five ratios that can help value investors find the most undervalued stocks in the market.
  4. Investing

    How To Use The P/E Ratio And PEG To Tell A Stock's Future

    The P/E ratio is used to calculate stock price valuation. However the PEG ratio includes earnings growth and can provide insight as to whether the P/E valuation is justified.
  5. Investing

    VEIEX: 3 Best Emerging Markets Equity Mutual Funds

    Learn about emerging markets and how your portfolio can benefit from them. Discover three unique high-dividend-paying emerging market mutual funds.
  6. Investing

    How to Find P/E And PEG Ratios

    If calculating the P/E and PEG ratios have you in the dark, these easy calculations should help.
  7. Investing

    Comparing the P/E, EPS And Earnings Yield

    Here are three ratios that help investors value stock returns.
  8. Investing

    4 Investment Strategies To Learn Before Trading

    The best thing about investing strategies is they’re flexible.
  9. Investing

    4 Signs Your Value Stock May Be Overvalued

    Value investing can make you money, but you have to look for traps. Overvalued stocks often correct, which means investors need to know when to get out.
Frequently Asked Questions
  1. Why Could A Company Have A Negative Gross Profit Margin?

    There are several reasons why a company might experience a loss in gross margins including poor marketing, ineffective pricing ...
  2. What are the three phases of a completed initial public offering (IPO) transformation process?

    An initial public offering (IPO) represents a private company's first offering of its equity to public investors.
  3. After an initial public offering, does a company profit from increases in its share price?

    The short answer is "no." To understand why, you have to know how the market works.
  4. What is the difference between the equity method and the proportional consolidation method?

    Discover the differences between the equity method and the proportional consolidation method of joint venture accounting, ...
Trading Center